California Judge Rules Motorist Can’t Use Smartphone Map

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

SAN FRANCISCO — Steven Spriggs was stopped in a traffic jam near downtown Fresno and thought nothing of whipping out his iPhone 4 and clicking on the map feature to see if there was an alternate route around the construction mess.

He was startled when he looked up and saw a California Highway Patrol motorcycle officer ordering him to pull over. He showed the officer that he was looking at a map and not texting or talking.

“‘Pull over,'” Spriggs recalled the officer as saying. “‘It’s in your hand.'”

A little more than a year later, Spriggs is at the heart of a novel court case that has technology blogs and social media sites buzzing about the $160 ticket plus court costs he was ordered to pay for “distracted driving.”

A court commissioner and then a three-judge appellate panel of the Superior Court found Spriggs guilty of violating a California law that bans motorists from texting or conducting phone conversations with hand-held devices.

The judges rejected Spriggs’ argument that they were expanding the law by refusing to toss out the ticket he got in January 2012.

Spriggs, who graduated from law school but isn’t a practicing attorney, represented himself before the commissioner and then the appeals panel. He initially brought a paper map to court to argue that it was legal to hold it while driving. Not persuaded, the traffic court commissioner found him guilty.

Next, he appealed to the three-judge panel of Fresno Superior Court, arguing in a legal brief that the iPhone has a flashlight feature and other functions that can be useful to a driver and aren’t as dangerous as texting or talking. That hearing last all of 30 seconds because no one from the CHP or district attorney’s office appeared to oppose the appeal by Spriggs.

He still lost.

Fresno County Judge Kent Hamlin, writing on March 21 for the three-judge panel upholding the commissioner’s ruling, said “the primary evil sought to be avoided is the distraction the driver faces when using his or her hands to operate the phone. That distraction would be present whether the wireless telephone was being used as a telephone, a GPS navigator, a clock or a device for sending and receiving text messages and emails.”

The ruling doesn’t apply outside of Fresno County.

Nevertheless, Spriggs said he is troubled that police can now pull over motorists they suspect of simply holding their mobile phones.

Spriggs, a fundraiser for Fresno State University, said he’s unsure if he has the time or money to pursue further appeals to the California Court of Appeal and the state Supreme Court.

“I’m just a little guy who is frustrated,” Spriggs said. “I don’t see how they can extend this law.”

He actually supports the prohibition on texting and conversing on hand-held devices while driving, saying his adult son’s leg was badly broken in 2010 when he was struck by a motorist who was chatting on a mobile phone.

Judge Hamlin acknowledged in his ruling that changes in the law may be needed.

“It may be argued that the Legislature acted arbitrarily when it outlawed all ‘hands-on’ use of a wireless telephone while driving, even though the legal use of one’s hands to operate myriad other devices poses just as great a risk to the safety of other motorists,” the judge wrote in the March 21 ruling. “It may also be argued that prohibiting driving while using ‘electronic wireless communications devices’ for texting and emailing, while acknowledging and failing to prohibit perhaps even more distracting uses of the same devices, is equally illogical and arbitrary.”

But the judge said it’s up to the Legislature to amend the law. Until then, Hamlin wrote, courts are compelled to deem illegal nearly all uses of hand-held phone by motorists.

  • The promise: Puts all your bills in one place.
    Price: Free
    Available on: Website, iPhone, Android

    Ready to go paperless? Manilla lets you see your bills at a glance and, if you opt in, alerts you via email, SMS, or smartphone notification when one is coming due. The service can’t process payments: You click on an account to log on to the biller’s site. Manilla also keeps tabs on when frequent-flier miles and other rewards are set to expire. The company makes money by charging partners to host their bills digitally, so firms no longer have to pay to send you a paper statement.

    Manilla

  • The promise: Determines which credit card is best.
    Price: Free
    Available on:  iPhone, Android

    If you have multiple cards — and especially if some have awards that change frequently or give extra points at, say, gas stations — this app will help you use them strategically.

    Choose a merchant, and the program calculates which of your cards will give you the best deal (it may also show you a related ad).

    Even rewards junkies sometimes use the wrong card, says Randy Peterson, a frequent-flier expert at InsideFlyer.com: "Wallaby gets rid of the guesswork."

    Wallaby

  • The fight: Account aggregation
    Looking for a user-friendly budgeting helper that will put all your financial data in one spot? Two good ones face off.

    STRENGTHS

    Mint: Easy to use. Create and track a budget in a few clicks. Sends bill reminders. Plus, it’s free.
    HelloWallet: Analyzes your accounts and gives advice on how to save more and avoid bank fees.

    DOWNSIDES

    Mint: Some dislike how the site gets a cut from its suggested credit cards.
    HelloWallet: The price is steep for an aggregation site. The first 30 days are free, but then it costs $8.95 a month.

    THE WINNER

    Mint: Certain employers offer HelloWallet as a free benefit. If yours does, go for it. Otherwise the service doesn’t have the features to justify its price.

    Availability: Both apps are available on their individual websites, the iPhone and Android.

    Head-to-head: Mint vs. HelloWallet

  • The promise: Scans your credit and debit cards for "gray charges."
    Price: Free for up to three credit cards
    Available on: Website, iPhone

    BillGuard spots charges you may miss, like the "free" credit report that signed you up for credit monitoring. The service "saves time people spend poring over their statements," says Aite Group analyst Ron Shevlin.

    The site also helps with billing disputes. So far, the firm says, users have gotten $1.2 million in refunds.

    The app is available only through Apple Passbook and can’t be used on an iPad.

    BillGuard

  • The promise: Compares your energy bills with those of similar homes and gives suggestions for how to shrink costs.
    Price: Free
    Available on: iPhone, Android

    Describe your house, and the site, which makes money by licensing its technology to companies looking to reduce their energy use, calculates how much you might save.
    Wattzon gives information about improvements — such as adding insulation or using efficient light bulbs — as well as associated rebates and tax credits.

    WattzOn

  • The fight: Internet talk and text apps
    Finding the right VoIP app can help keep your phone bill under control. Are you already using the best one, or is it time to try something new?

    STRENGTHS

    Skype: Free IM, voice, and video calls to Skype users. Low-cost calls may let you try a cheaper cell plan, says CNET’s Rick Broida.
    Viber: Call or text any Viber user for free. Automatically searches your contacts for other users. No ads.

    DOWNSIDES

    Skype: The free service is supported by ads targeted to your age, gender, and location. The premium service costs $4.99 a month.
    Viber: Routes calls to non-Viber users through your cell plan. Video calls not supported.

    THE WINNER

    Skype: Yes, the ads are annoying, but Skype is still the more useful choice. Until Viber lets you talk to people who don’t have the app — without using your cell minutes — the service stays at No. 2.

    Availability: Both apps are available on the iPhone, Android and Windows Phone. Skype is available on its website. Viber is also available on the BlackBerry.

    Head-to-head: Skype vs. Viber

  • The promise: Alerts you the moment an item you want goes on sale.
    Price: Free
    Available on: Website, browser add-on

    Add Hukkster to the bookmark bar of any major browser. When you spot, say, a nice duvet at Macys.com, click on the item, then on your "Hukk It" bookmark. You’ll get an email or text if the price falls.

    Choose to get the heads-up as soon as the product is marked down, when the price drops by 25%, or only for a dip of 50% or more. If you decide to buy, Hukkster gets a cut.

    Hukkster

  • The promise: Finds discounts to apply to your online-shopping order.
    Price: Free
    Available on: Browser add-on

    This Chrome-only browser extension (get it at JoinHoney.com) adds a "Find Savings" button to the checkout page of 100-plus shopping sites, including Amazon.com.

    Hit the button, and Honey will find and apply any available discounts to your order. The service saves time and money, says Lifehacker editor Adam Dachis: "It spares you the extra step of testing the coupon codes."

    Honey

  • The fight: Price comparison apps
    Both apps will scan a product’s bar code and search for the best available price. Which one is the best price detective?

    STRENGTHS

    RedLaser: The most comprehensive search results. Particularly strong on nearby brick-and-mortar listings.
    InvisibleHand: Often lists shipping costs. Save a scanned item and get an alert if the price drops or hits a certain level.

    DOWNSIDES

    RedLaser: Shipping and tax aren’t usually factored into price comparisons.
    InvisibleHand: Searches only online results. So far the app is available just for iOS.

    THE WINNER

    It’s a draw: Having two scanners is a good idea. The apps use different algorithms, and one may catch a deal the other missed, says bargain-shopping expert Andrea Woroch.

    Availability: RedLaser is available on the iPhone, Android and Windows Phone. InvisibleHand is only on the iPhone. Both apps are free.

    Head-to-head: RedLaser vs. InvisibleHand

  • Price: Free
    Available on: Website
    Looking for the right savings account, credit card, cable company, or wireless service? Tell BillShrink a bit about your needs and usage, and the site will find your best match.
    BillShrink
  • Continue Best Apps to Manage Your Money

    More from CNNMoney:

    Best travel apps
    Six secrets to a dream retirement
    5 family vacation bargains

Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Share